![]() If Frodo and his Eagle escort failed, Sauron would have gotten his Ring back, and all would have been lost, then and there. That would draw the attention of Sauron, the Nazgûl and the entire host of Mordor. Let's say, hypothetically, that the Eagles were strong enough and agreed to undertake the suicide mission. If all of that wasn't enough, there's one final in-universe reason that the Eagles didn't take Frodo to Mount Doom. ![]() Tolkien knew it was a bad idea because, if nothing else, it "spoils the account of escape." Even Jackson's movies portrayed the Eagles as a plot hole, but Zimmerman's treatment had the Eagles landing in the Shire early in the film. Tolkien clearly understood that he was playing with fire, and the Eagles couldn't become a fix-all. RELATED: Lord of the Rings: Is Gandalf’s Staff Magical? Among other issues, he wrote about the use of the Eagles, saying, "The Eagles are a dangerous 'machine.' I have used them sparingly, and that is the absolute limit of their credibility or usefulness." While Tolkien liked some of the concept art, he took issue with much of Zimmerman's 55-page film treatment. One attempt was made by Morton Grady Zimmerman. There were multiple early attempts at adapting Tolkien's work into a film, and many of them failed outright. Tolkien's Letters Provide More Insight Into The Eagles' Capabilities When Gwaihir did fly into Mordor in The Return of the King, it was only after Frodo destroyed the Ring, Sauron's "Eye" collapsed and the Witch-king had been defeated. That was something that Gandalf simply would not have asked of him. Flying directly into a fully-powerful Mordor would have been little better than a suicide mission, even if Frodo destroyed the Ring in the process. RELATED: Lord of the Rings: Who Are Morgoth's Greatest Servants (& What Happened to Them)?Įach of those three occasions, though, were low-stakes. In The Return of the King, as Gandalf asked the Windlord to rescue Frodo, the wizard said, "Twice you have borne me, Gwaihir my friend Thrice shall pay for all, if you are willing." Gandalf did save Gwaihir from a poisoned arrow before the events of The Hobbit, so maybe that was why the Great Eagle was so willing to help Gandalf on three different occasions. The Eagles were not at Gandalf's command, but Gwaihir did seemingly owe him a debt. Case and point: most of them stayed out of the more human affairs of Middle-earth. They had their own interests and their own decisions to make. That meant that the Great Eagles were not simply at Gandalf's beck and call, able to be summoned for every little thing. In the book, however, Gwaihir was already looking for Gandalf at the behest of Radagast the Brown. Secondly, in The Lord of the Rings films, Gwaihir rescued Gandalf from Isengard after the wizard called him with a moth. I was sent to bear tidings not burdens." Thus, flying to Mordor might have been a bit far, even for the Great Eagles. The Eagle's response was, "Many leagues, but not to the ends of the earth. As proof, when Gwaihir the Windlord rescued Gandalf from Isengard, the wizard asked Gwaihir how far he could fly him. Eagles, on the other hand, were not Maiar spirits with unlimited strength and energy. Gandalf was essentially a ring-bearing angel, but even his body would become tired. The first reason that the Eagles couldn't have taken Frodo was a mere matter of physical practicality. ![]() RELATED: Lord of the Rings Anatomy: 5 Weird Facts About Frodo, Bilbo & Hobbits’ Bodies The Eagles Have Limitations in The Lord of the Rings Tolkien's books and additional material, it becomes much clearer why the Eagles couldn't have flown Frodo to Mount Doom. From simply watching the films, one would certainly come to the conclusion that the Eagles could have fixed everyone's problems, but it wasn't supposed to be that simple. It's true that Jackson's trilogy made the Eagles out to be a deus ex machina on multiple occasions. With that in mind, if the Eagles could have flown Frodo to Mount Doom in the first place, it would have saved everyone a lot of trouble. After they destroyed Sauron's One Ring, Eagles swooped down and saved Frodo and Sam from the enclosing fires of a ruptured Mount Doom. However, the end of The Return of the King made it seem like much of that could have been avoided. #Who made the lord of the rings ring movie#Ever since Peter Jackson's epic movie trilogy, many Lord of the Ringsfans have complained about one particular "plot hole." Frodo, Sam and company journeyed over a thousand miles and defeated countless foes to prevent Sauron's rise to power.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |